Revision and reviewer response

Reviewer comments, answered point by point, before the deadline.

A revision request means the journal is interested. We answer every comment clearly and respectfully, revise the manuscript with tracked changes, and resubmit on time, so the editor has every reason to accept.

  • Plagiarism report with every manuscript
  • Updates on WhatsApp at every step
  • You approve before anything is submitted
Response to reviewersMajor revision · 14 comments
Reviewer 1.3 · “Justify the sample size” · power analysis added, p. 6Done
Reviewer 2.1 · “Compare with recent work” · 6 studies addedDone
Reviewer 2.4 · polite disagreement with evidenceWith you
Journal deadline · 9 days left · on track
Revised manuscript with tracked changes + clean copy
What you receive

Everything the editor asks for, in the form editors expect.

A revision is judged on how completely and clearly each comment is handled. We deliver all the files the resubmission needs.

Point-by-point response letter

Each reviewer comment quoted, followed by what was changed and where, with page and line numbers.

Revised manuscript, tracked

Every change visible with tracked changes or highlights, as the journal asks, plus a clean copy.

Extra analysis where asked

Additional statistics, comparisons, figures or tables, built from your existing data.

Updated literature

Recent studies added where reviewers asked for them, cited correctly in the journal’s style.

Language and clarity

The sections reviewers found unclear rewritten, and the whole paper polished for language.

Resubmission

The revised files uploaded with your approval before the deadline, and the proof shared with you.

Step by step

How we handle your revision.

You see the plan for each comment before we write, and you approve the response before it reaches the journal.

01
Same day

We read the decision and the comments.

You share the decision letter, the reviewers’ comments, your manuscript and the deadline. We confirm what is needed and the time it will take.

  • Deadline checked first
  • Price agreed before work starts
02
Plan

We sort every comment.

Each comment marked as a change, an addition, a clarification or a polite disagreement, so you see exactly what will be done.

  • Nothing ignored
  • Your input on any comment that needs your data
03
Revise

We revise the manuscript and draft the response.

The changes made in the paper with tracked changes, and the response letter written comment by comment with page and line references.

  • Tracked and clean copies
  • Extra analysis where needed
04
Approve

You review the response and the paper.

You read the revised manuscript and the letter, and ask for any changes. We finalise once you approve.

  • Your approval before resubmission
  • Co-authors kept informed
05
Resubmit

We resubmit and track the next decision.

The files uploaded before the deadline with your consent, and the next decision followed and shared on WhatsApp.

  • Proof shared straight away
  • Further rounds handled the same way
How a good response reads

Thank the reviewer, say what changed, show where.

Reviewer 2, comment 3: The authors should compare their results with recent studies.

Response: We thank the reviewer for this suggestion. We have added a comparison with six studies published between 2023 and 2025 (Section 5.2, page 14, lines 312–340, and new Table 6). Our method improves accuracy by 3.1% over the best of these, and we discuss why in the following paragraph.

Straight answers

What we promise, and what no honest service can.

The journal’s editor and reviewers decide every acceptance. Anyone who guarantees it is either guessing or selling a journal you should avoid.

We promise

  • Every comment answered, none skipped
  • A respectful, evidence-based reply to every reviewer
  • Resubmission planned before the journal’s deadline
  • Tracked and clean copies of the manuscript
  • Your approval before anything goes back to the journal

We never

  • Change your results to please a reviewer
  • Invent data, analysis or references
  • Miss a deadline without warning you first
  • Resubmit without your consent
Questions

Questions about revision and reviewer response

Anything else, message us on WhatsApp and a person replies within working hours.

WhatsApp the team

+91 63694 37154, 98944 14299

Open WhatsApp

Can you help with a paper you did not write?

Yes. Send us the manuscript, the reviewers’ comments and the journal’s deadline. We read everything, tell you what each comment needs, and prepare the response and the revised manuscript.

What is the difference between a major and a minor revision?

A minor revision asks for small changes: wording, a few references, clearer figures. A major revision asks for real work: more analysis, more data, a rewritten section or a changed argument. Both mean the journal wants the paper, provided the changes are made well.

What if a reviewer asks for an experiment or data I do not have?

We tell you straight away. Sometimes the request can be met with an extra analysis of your existing data, a clearer explanation or a stated limitation. If it truly needs new data, we help you write a respectful reply that explains why, and you decide.

Do we have to agree with every reviewer comment?

No. Where a reviewer is mistaken, the response disagrees politely with evidence and references. Editors accept a well-argued disagreement; they do not accept a comment that was ignored.

How quickly can you turn a revision around?

Minor revisions usually take three to seven days, major revisions one to three weeks, depending on what is asked. We always plan to finish before the journal’s deadline, and help you ask for an extension when it is genuinely needed.

My paper was rejected. Can you help?

Yes. We read the rejection and the reviews with you, fix what the reviewers rightly criticised, and prepare the paper for a better-suited journal from a new shortlist.
Free quote

Send us the reviewers’ comments. We reply with a plan and a quote.

No cost and no obligation. We read what you send, suggest the right journals or the right next step, and tell you the price and the timeline before any work starts.

  1. Step 1We read your details and call or message you on WhatsApp within 4–5 business hours
  2. Step 2You get a written plan: target journals, work involved, price and dates
  3. Step 3Work starts only after you agree, and you follow every step on WhatsApp
+91 63694 37154, 98944 14299
info@paperflowpublications.com

Coimbatore, Tamil Nadu, India · we work with researchers across India and abroad

Get a free quote

Takes under a minute. Your details stay private.

Please enter your name.
Enter a 10-digit number, with or without +91.
Enter an email like name@university.ac.in.

We use these details only to reply about your paper. See our privacy policy.

Call +91 63694 37154, 98944 14299 Chat on WhatsApp